The new dungeon is great! My thoughts...
Difficulty: Hard.
I wish it wasn't this hard not because I don't like challenging dungeons but because it could be cool if new players can actually do this dungeon SINCE especially all you need is a sub to access this dungeon. As of now this dungeon isn't newbie friendly and finding non-hair pulling pugs will be very difficult. I didn't like sections of dungeons where it was a DPS race... please I'm a guardian ..even now global is asking for ONLY Conqs/DTs.
Loot: Good...sort of.
Its good loot for the circumstances. But the dungeon is too hard for those that will fully appreciate the loot and for those that could do it probably already have as good if not better loot. Understandably you couldn't make the loot better then T4 but in reality all you need is one tiny item (say a helmet) to be slightly better then T4 for people to grind/play the area again and again to get that one piece of loot. Also, there seems to be no full plate armors for guardians..just a bunch of +crit full plates(I know all the devs play DTs but please throw us guards a bone..perhaps some +hate rings or something we're dying here.)
Duration: Ehh its just a tad too long but after doing it for a bit it's OK.
Feel: Out did yourselves this time. I know much of the concept/art/structure of the game was done by your Montreal studios while you guys had a full team.... but I need to tip my hat to you all. I really really am eager to meet the walking man/dark pharaoh/Mr. Flagg in person at the end of all this.... PLEASE MAKE HIM MIND SHATTERINGLY DIFFICULT.
Final grade: B+/A- ..congrats I have very high standards but you guys did exceptionally well for the most part.