I won't be saying that current BoA is fine, but you gotta admit the pre-revamp version was a mess.
Certainly it did require skill to execute, in the same way that riding a bike with twisted wheels and no handlebar requires skill, I guess.
The implementation was so convoluted that in the end it did not really match the description and would not kb stuff you thought it would according to tooltip, would kb stuff you thought it would not, not to mention it would proc stuff that should proc on knockback without even kbing anything(*). The revamp fixed all these discrepancies... by oversimplifying the ability (alas).
(*) not that it'd matter anymore since later BfC rendered Assail completely pointless.
-- Ieronon, QQror --
-- Deutter, holy potato --
If the sin manages to dodge the barbs cc's, the sin can easilly win..Unless he gets the speed buff, kites and comes back like an angry bee when his cd's are reset. I really like to duel sins on my barb, and vice versa.
Also, decap isn't very popular anymore, it's only good against a few classes since you waste so much points to get it.
Bit banging on dead horse with barb vs sin since many people believe in sin being some undying monsters that can only be killed by soldiers. But i kind of agree with you, if sin manage to dodge barb cc with cats paw and timely double tapping he should have advantage, but than again barb have longer reach and a lot of cc's, so its always interesting fight between good players.
The thing that is debatable is usage of decap, while i dont like that build and dont play it, i tried it and seen many barbs doing good with it. Its cheesy play style but it is efficient on clothies, light armor or undergeared players. knock, staggering blow, finishing blow ATG and decap is quick and with some lucky crit big burst.
You know a lot of classess have aoe ccs'...necro(fear),sin(fear),guard(fear)...conqs fear on the other hand its a combo and you can miss,..tosses(aoe root),DTs(aoe fear)..so..why is it that conq isnt suposed to have an aoe cc????and all that aoe ccs that i mentioned require no skill..sooo why not conq is not allowed to have an aoe cc???????????????????????