LOL I don't know what you guys are talking about. I have three casters that I play often and I have nothing against casters, nor do I ever have trouble with sins on them. Only thing I hate in pvp are tanks that play like pussies.
Suctum regards to your minimal gear and aa deal, none of it is plausible for a new rogue, esp on without a good guild to carry them through. Have you rolled a new 80? How do you get 3-6 points for free, cus' it's certainly not that many. Pressing and decisive both cost 2 just to spec 1 point. Both TW/FH takes forever to get, even if you do get carried through yag loops that have another rogue to do your work. Compare that to a demo or necro, do they have to get UC to go to yag? No. Demos will have an easier time to gain gear and AA than new rogues.
And you say it's about 2 weeks or less to be geared and AA'd enough on a rogue to be competitive? That's so off base. But by that logic, any demo, necro, dt can be the same with your "minimal AA and gear" erroneous description. So your opinion that sins and rangers suffer the least from bad gear and limited AA is wrong. Sins and rangers that spec tribrid with minimal AA and gear gets destroyed in pvp, demos necros and dts who do don't and are still "competitive". Here's my pve spec'd pvp 2 DT with your minimal gear and aa, with only 1 in vindication :
http://i562.photobucket.com/albums/s...ps1ab28fc3.jpg
That was the last time I played it in pvp. I similarily gave up pvping on my conq. I rolled debt and can specifically b/c they were underpowered before, but they became jokes so I gave them up.
Calore, if you've ever faced a decent caster on a melee, what they do well is to chain their ccs and dmg spells together, necro, demo, the same. You can not only chain major and minor ccs on a necro, you can use pet stagger as well. Any time you get close, they pop off a certain cc and kite away.
BTW, LO is very very easy to deal with on a caster. I'm sure you know pvp is more about burst than sustained like pve. You can very well cc a sin, proc LO, kite away, wait til LO is up, then force all your burst dmg to burn it down when it has no immunity anymore. The only time it becomes a problem is when the sin know to stack LO with dull pain, b/c unless you kite to a teammate, or just have better movement than the sin, you can't do enough before one of the sin's cc or dmg cylce is up.
Btw, discuss what I say, not make assumptions about what I hate or haven't played caster vs good sin. I can talk out of my butt too but it won't be a discussion.